As a criminal defense attorney with over 25 years of experience, Sean Buckley has seen countless cases where someone is asked to take a polygraph test, believing it will prove their innocence. The truth is, however, that agreeing to take a polygraph is rarely in your best interest. While many people think a "lie detector" test will clear their name, it can often have the opposite effect. Let me explain why. At The Law Offices of Sean Buckley, we have the experience and knowledge to guide you through these tough situations and help protect your rights.
1. Polygraphs Are Not Scientifically Reliable:
A polygraph measures physiological responses like heart rate, blood pressure, and respiration rate while you answer questions. The assumption is that these responses change when you're lying, but in reality, many innocent people can experience anxiety or nervousness during questioning. This can cause the polygraph to incorrectly indicate that you're lying, even when you're not. Conversely, a guilty person may not show any physiological signs of stress, making the test completely unreliable.
2. Polygraphs Are Used as an Interrogation Tool:
Contrary to what law enforcement may tell you, the primary purpose of a polygraph is not to determine if someone is lying. Instead, it is often used as an interrogation tactic to get a suspect or witness to provide additional information that can be used against them. After the test, the examiner might claim that you "failed" one or more questions, even if you were truthful. The examiner will then ask you to provide more information to "explain" the supposed failure.
This is a psychological strategy. The goal is to pressure you into making a statement that could either incriminate you or undermine your defense. The additional information you provide can easily turn into evidence—direct or circumstantial—that harms your case. Even if you’re completely innocent, this tactic can cause you to inadvertently reveal damaging information.
3. Statements Made During Polygraph Testing Are Admissible in Court:
While polygraph results themselves are generally not admissible in court, statements made to the examiner during the post-test interview are admissible against you. So, if you take a polygraph and then attempt to explain away a “failed” test, you are essentially putting yourself at risk. Anything you say could be used against you later in court.
Law enforcement may try to convince you that giving an explanation will help clear up any confusion, but in reality, it’s just another way for them to gather evidence against you. This is why I strongly advise my clients to avoid polygraphs altogether, especially without legal representation.
4. The Police Aren’t Trying to Help You—They’re Trying to Build a Case Against You:
If the police ask you to take a polygraph test, don’t be fooled into thinking they're offering to help you. The reality is, they already suspect you. If they had enough evidence to clear you of wrongdoing, they wouldn’t be asking you to take the test in the first place.
By agreeing to take the test, you’re essentially helping them build a case against you. Even if you pass the polygraph, there’s no guarantee it will make a difference. If you fail the test, however, it could be used to further justify their suspicion and potentially lead to charges.
5. You Have a Constitutional Right to Remain Silent:
You have a constitutional right to remain silent. This is one of your most important protections when you’re facing criminal charges or investigation. You don’t have to participate in any questioning or testing, including a polygraph. In fact, refusing to take a polygraph is often the best move.
If the police don’t have enough evidence to charge you with a crime, then saying “no” to a polygraph won’t harm your case—it could actually help. It’s important to remember that law enforcement doesn’t need your cooperation to investigate you, and your silence can prevent them from gathering information that could hurt your defense.
Conclusion:
Polygraph tests may seem like a quick way to clear your name, but the truth is that they are unreliable and often used as a tactic to gather information that could harm your case. If you’re ever asked to take a polygraph, remember that you have the right to remain silent and refuse to cooperate. Don’t fall for the myth that polygraphs can protect you. Consult with an experienced criminal defense attorney like myself, and we’ll work together to ensure your rights are protected.
Innocence deserves the fiercest defense, and that begins with hiring a criminal defense attorney. Just as no two cases are alike, the same holds true for lawyers. Criminal defense attorney Sean Buckley has over 25 years of experience handling a wide spectrum of cases ranging from highly intricate matters to misdemeanors. With his great expertise your rights will be protected, you'll have a strategic defense tailored just for your specific needs and at the Law Offices of Sean Buckley we'll stand as your strongest ally in the fight for justice. Don't let a criminal charge dictate your future; get the help of criminal defense attorney Sean Buckley and reclaim your innocence.
To explore your legal options and have a specially crafted defense strategy tailored to your case, schedule a FREE CASE EVALUATION with Sean Buckley, an experienced and knowledgable State of Mississippi criminal defense attorney serving Biloxi, Gulfport, Harrison County, Jackson County and throughout South Mississippi. With his extensive experience, your rights and reputation are in capable hands!
Call us today and get the defense you deserve!
228-933-4411
Comments